"Prosperity is a way of living and thinking, and not just money or things. Poverty is a way of living and thinking, and not just a lack of money or things. "
Eric Butterworth
When Ben was about 4 or 5 years old he asked my wife to buy something. I really don't remember what it was but My wife said that it was a lot of money and that we didn't have the money for that purchase. His response was, “Then let's go to the bank machine and get some money!”
Wow! That should have been a big old red flag to my wife and I that we had to teach some Ben about money and also to help him think about his values around money. To be honest, we failed. If I could go back in time 15 years, I would do a very different job about teaching my kids about money. But I have missed the best teaching opportunity and not I have to try to play catch-up. I can still do a decent job, but it will not be the same.
The very first thing you have to do to answer the question, “Should You Give Your Kids Allowance?” is to think about the values that you want to teach your child about money. Think about the following questions:
-
Do you want your child to think that money comes with no effort?
-
Do you want your child to think that money comes for doing the things you would otherwise have to do , like washing your dishes?
-
Do you want to teach your child about saving money? Tithing? Investing?
-
Do you want to teach your child that money is a source of strife and disharmony?
Once you have thought about these question, you are ready to start thinking about allowance.
Some people give allowance to their kids with no strings attached. $1 each week whether the child has done chores or not. As we call that in our family, “Just for being a part of the family.” Some say that this can create a situation in which your child expects money to come like manna from heaven. Do nothing and money appears. Is this the attitude you want your child to have? Some would call this a way of showing love. You can explain to your child that the money is simply a token of your love. The money is like the flowers you might bring your lover, or the book you might buy for a friend as a present. Do you want your child to be reminded regularly, in a concrete way, that you love them?
Some people give money for doing chores like making their bed and clearing the table. This might create a situation in which your child expects money for things they would do anyway. They may get a rude awakening when they “get out into the real world.” Others say this is simply an incentive to diminish arguing. If so, will you not give allowance if your child doesn't do these basic chores.
Others only give money for “special” chores that would not otherwise be expected of your child. For some that might be mowing the lawn. For others it might be painting a fence. The problem with this approach might be that your child may not have a regular source of income and will get used to boom and bust times and may not learn to budget. Perhaps you can give an everyday “special” chore, like making your bed!
One idea that I heard from Amanda van der Gulik is to pass money for lessons through your child. So for example, if your child wants guitar lessons, give your child $25 each week and then they will pay for the lesson. This will help them to learn the value of money.
The bottom line in all these ideas is that you have to consider what you are trying to create and plan from there. The bad news is that I cannot tell you what is right for you. The good news is that there is no wrong answer, only the right answer for you!

